Ontario Government Health Spending Trends: It’s Complicated

 

The 2025 CIHI National Health Expenditure trends are out with the key national findings being that total health care spending in Canada is expected to reach $399 billion in 2025, or $9,626 per Canadian with that expenditure representing 12.7% of Canada’s gross domestic product (GDP) in 2025. Total health care spending in Canada is expected to grow by 4.2% in 2025 following a 6.1% increase in 2024 and 7.4% in 2023.  I will be dealing with the national numbers elsewhere but my interest in this post is Ontario provincial government health spending which for 2025 is estimated at $93 billion up 3.3 percent from the year previous and not as large an increase as 2024 at 6.3 percent.  While the provincial government makes much of its spending increases being at historic levels, a 3.3 percent increase does not keep up with inflation and population.

Figure 1 plots real per capita Ontario government health spending in 2025 dollars (deflated with the CIHI’s Total Health Care Implicit Price Index) along with the spending to GDP ratio for the 1975 to 2025 period and while the overall trend is upwards, the period since the pandemic is particularly noteworthy.  After the pandemic surge in real per capita provincial government health spending of 8.5 percent in 2020 and 4.9 percent in 2021, each subsequent year has seen negative growth with 2025 declining just over one-fifth of one percent. However, at $5,750 per capita ($2025), spending in 2025 remains nearly 10 percent above the 2019 amount of $5,233 ($2025) implying average spending growth since 2019 of approximately 1.7 percent annually.

 

 

What is more interesting in Figure 1 is that while real per capita provincial government health spending has been trending down since 2021, its share of provincial GDP has been going up.  How can that be?  As anemic as provincial health spending growth has been relative to inflation and population, it turns out Ontario’s economic growth has been even more anemic.  This is not the greatest news.

Figure 2 illustrates that despite slightly negative real per capita growth in provincial government health spending; there is considerable variation across categories that may signal what the government’s priorities are.  Real per capita hospital spending declined 3.5 percent in 2024 but is expected to rise 0.5 percent in 2025.  After a 5.3 percent increase in 2024, real per capita other institutions (i.e., long term care) will decline one fifth of one percent with a similar pattern for physicians at 5.1 percent in 2024 but -1.4 percent for 2025.  Other professional (e.g. optometrists) drugs, public health and administration are being hit with consecutive declines in real per capita spending.  Other health spending including home and community care is seeing an increase in 2025 while real per capita capital spending will rise nearly 20 percent in 2025.  While renewing capital infrastructure in provincial government health spending is welcome, all that shiny new equipment and buildings will need hospital and physician services as well as drug spending down the road.

 

 

And if you are interested in something different, Figures 3 and 4 present provincial government health spending by age categories to look at what an aging population has been doing to provincial government health spending.   Figure 3 plots per capita provincial (nominal dollars) government spending by age group for four years spanning the 2000 to 2023 period and they show the typical expected u-shaped cost curve with spending highest at the very early ages of birth to about 4 years, then rising gradually and growing more dramatically after the late 50s.  In 2023, the per capita spending for a person under 1 year of age averaged $17,591 dollars, for a 25–29-year-old it was $2,594, for a 55–59-year-old it was $5,037 and for an 85–89-year-old it was $29,415.  Indeed, health care costs can rise dramatically over the later years of the life cycle.

 

 

However, the astute gentle reader will note that the profiles by age have been shifting upward over time.  That is, spending has been going up for all the age categories and figure 4 plots the percent changes in per capita provincial government spending from 2000 to 2023 by age category. While spending per capita is highest for the elderly, growth over time has been the greatest in much younger demographics.  The greatest growth was in the age 10-14 category at 207 percent, followed by the below 1-year category at 204 percent, then 194 percent for those aged 5-9, 172 percent for those aged 15-19 and 169 percent for those aged 1-4 years.  After that come 35–39-year-olds at 153 percent, 40–44-year-olds at 151 percent, and 45–49-year-olds at 145 percent.

 

 

The smallest increases over the 2000 to 2023 period?  At the bottom are 80–84-year-olds at 90 percent, next highest are 75–79-year-olds at 94 percent and then 70–74-year-olds at 96 percent.  Health spending does rise with age, and much more is spent per capita on the elderly than the young.  However, in percentage terms, the greatest increases have been in the population aged 19 years and younger followed by the population aged 30 to 64 and 90 plus.  Lowest increases are in the 20-29 age groups and the 70-89 age groups.  This is an interesting and somewhat counter intuitive results given the conventional wisdom is that health care costs are being driven largely by an aging population.  It would appear the drivers of provincial government health care spending are more complicated than one might imagine.

Note: Livio Di Matteo is a member of the CIHI NHEX Advisory Panel. 

Ontario Health Spending: What's Up and What's Down

 The Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI) has released its 2024 National Health Expenditure Trends data and it paints an overall picture of rising health spending.  As I have noted elsewhere, total health-care spending in Canada is expected to increase by 5.7 percent in 2024, after rising 4.5 percent in 2023 and only 1.7 percent in 2022 coming on the heels of the pandemic.  The picture for provincial government health spending is also one of increase but once adjusted for population and inflation, the results are more mixed particularly if one looks at changes since the year before the pandemic.  Over the period 2019 to 2024, British Columbia and Prince Edward Island see the largest increases in real per capita provincial government spending at 17 and 16 percent respectively while at the bottom are Manitoba and Nova Scotia, which over the five years have seen their per capita provincial government health spending stay essentially flat.  Ontario, over this same period saw an increase of just under seven percent.

 

 

Figure 1 plots real per capita Ontario provincial government health spending ($2010) from 1975 to the present and the evidence shows that since 2010, real per capita health spending spending growth was lackluster at best rising from $3,617 to $3,783 - an increase of of 4.6 percent or about half a percent annually.  After 2019, the pandemic saw a ramping up provincial government health spending to a peak of $4,316 in 2021 - an increase over two years of almost 14 percent.  Since 2021, there has been a decline in real per capita spending and in 2024 it is estimated to sit at $4,040 - for a decline of about 6 percent.  Nevertheless, real per capita provincial government health spending in 2024 is still projected to be 6.8 percent higher than 2019.

 

What is quite interesting is how spending by expenditure category has performed over the 2019 to 2024 period.  Figure 2 plots the percentage change in real per capita provincial government health spending by category.  Over this five year period, the largest increase has been for real per capita spending on other institutions - namely, long-term care - at nearly 50 percent.  This is of course understandable in the wake of what transpired in long-term care homes during the pandemic as well as the promise to build more long-term care beds for an aging population.  Next is home and community care at 10.7 percent , followed by public health at 9.3 percent and then hospitals at 8 percent.  Other professionals is next with an increase of 5.3 percent followed by capital at 3.2 percent.  What comes next however is even more interesting .  All other health care net of home and community care spending is down by about a third of one percent.  Spending on provincial government drug plans in real per capita terms is down 4.4 percent while physician spending is down 5.8 percent.  Finally, real per capita provincial government health spending on health administration is down nearly 24 percent. 

 The surprise here is that spending has dropped on two items that directly affects a lot of individuals in Ontario - namely, government paid for prescription drugs and physician services.   Obviously, if one measures availability of physician services by how much is being spent per person after population growth and inflation, it is obvious that Ontario is having trouble keeping up in this category.  With an aging population, the decline in physician and also drug plan spending is definitely going to be felt even if the provincial government asks us to take solace in the increases in long-term care, home care and hospital spending. 

The Four Ages of Ontario Government Health Spending

Understanding the pressures and challenges facing Ontario’s health care system and in particular - provincial government health spending – requires an overview of the numbers.  The Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI) via its National Health Expenditure Database provides a wealth of information on health spending in Canada.  The 2019 edition of the National Health Expenditure release allows us to piece together a broad picture of where health spending in Ontario has been over the last few decades. 

Figure 1 on total health spending in Ontario provides a view of total and provincial government health spending over the period 1975 to 2019 (with 2018 and 2019 being estimates).  They show steadily rising spending.  Total health spending on health in Ontario was $4.4 billion in 1975 and has grown to an estimated $100.5 billion.  Meanwhile, over the same period provincial government health spending has grown from $3.1 billion to $63.4 billion.  The massive growth in health spending over time is part of the conventional wisdom that health spending is unsustainable.

However, these numbers are nominal totals and do not take into consideration population, inflation or economic growth which are all necessary to provide context for these numbers.  Between 1975 and 2019, provincial government health spending in Ontario grew 20-fold while GDP grew 13-fold, population grew 1.7-fold and prices 5-fold.  

Rising Health Spending Is Not Just About Seniors

The Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI) has released its 23^rd annual report on health spending in Canada - National Health Expenditure Trends, 1975 to 2019.  As a member of the CIHI National Health Expenditures advisory panel, it is always great to see the wealth of data on trends in health spending across Canada.   Total health spending in Canada in 2019 is expected to reach $264.4 billion which represents an increase of 3.9 percent over last year and accounts for 11.6 percent of Canada’s GDP – a figure also up slightly from last year.  After a period of zero average annual growth in real per capita total health spending from 2010 to 2014, the period since 2014 has averaged about 1.4 percent a year.  This, however is lower than the average annual growth rate from 1996 to 2010 which was at 3.3 percent.  Health spending growth has resumed but on what currently seems like a more sustainable trajectory given that real per capita GDP growth is closer to 2 percent.

Much of the concern about rising health spending has focused on the effects of population aging.  Health spending does rise with age as Figure 1 below shows rather dramatically.  Aside from those aged less than 1-year, per capita provincial/territorial government health spending is well  below $5,000 until the 60-64 age group when it starts to rise above that threshold reaching over $30,000 for those aged over 90 years.  Yet, despite this surge after age 60, what is also interesting is that when the drivers of rising health spending are broken down, in 2019, aging per se only contributes 0.8 percentage points out of the 3.8 percent growth in public sector health spending – about 21 percent – with general inflation, population growth and other factors (eg. Technology and utilization) accounting for the rest.  It does lead one to wonder whether this is because today’s seniors are generally quite healthy compared to the past or perhaps whether there are unmet needs.


What is also interesting and seldom noted is that while provincial and territorial government per capita health spending is highest among seniors, over the last two decades, the rates of growth in per capita spending have not been for seniors.  Indeed, between 2000 and 2017, the highest average annual growth rates have been for children and youth aged 5 to 19, followed by children under age 1-year and adults aged 35-39 as shown in Figure 2.


Indeed, per capita spending for adults between the ages of 35 and 64 has been growing at a faster rate than those aged 65 to 89.  While, it is true that much lower per capita amounts are being spent on those below age 65, spending for this demographic has been growing much faster.  Again, this leads one to wonder given scarce resources whether there is an implicit transfer of resources underway away from seniors when it comes to new growth or whether younger people today have more health problems or utilize health care more than similarly aged groups in the past.  Given the epidemic of obesity and mental health issues among the young, perhaps this is having an impact on health spending needs and expenditures.

If a significant cohort shift in health care needs and utilization is underway is an interesting question. I suppose fully knowing if this is a recent development or has been underway for the last 50 years requires per capita age spending data going back quite a ways - I am only aware of the CIHI data going back to the mid 1990s or so.  This is an important issue.  While an aging population may only be contributing 21 percent of the increase in health spending now, if younger cohorts today have deteriorating health status or more health issues than in the past, they may be poised to be a more important driver of health spending both now and in the future.