When Budget Requests Collide: Thunder Bay 2026

  

Thunder Bay has released its planned 2026 operating budget and as usual there are a plethora of numbers, facts and figures splashed across our local media.  This year’s budget is especially interesting given that in the lead up to its release, the messaging from The City was that the tax levy increase would be held to 2.6 percent.  However, as it has emerged, this initially did not consider the rather large request from the Police Services Board of a 9.1 percent increase for their requirements as well as larger requests from other external boards. Apparently, those are 'external' and the City itself has done a good job of keeping its increases to 2.6 percent though one should add City Council needs to approve all of these increases if they are to go forward.

Given that police services alone account for 22 percent of the property tax levy, this has bumped up the proposed municipal levy increase to 4.4 percent though the City as usual is doing its after growth schtick and saying it is only 4 percent. With the Growth Plan setting 3 percent in the assessment growth as a target, we can joyfully anticipate the day when there will be a 4 percent levy increase but which only amounts to 1 percent after growth. And as usual, one also needs to factor in the rate-supported budget in all of this. The average residential household will see a 4.1 percent increase in their total Water and Wastewater charges bring the average per household up to $1,479.88 from $1,436.84.  As a further note, The City will also be expanding its employment in 2026 adding 57.1 Full Time Equivalent positions in areas such as safety and security, growth, service delivery and to run the 2026 municipal election.

 

As has been my practice, the accompanying figure plots Thunder Bay’s tax levy increases since 1990 to provide context.  The last four years have seen a distinct increase in the tax levy not only from the lows of the pandemic but from the period immediately pre-pandemic.  Over the 2023 to 2026 period, the levy increases average 4.7 percent putting this year’s increase slightly below the four-year average but well above the 2015 to 2022 period average of 3 percent.

Of course, the budget still must be ratified and there is a period of public input but the current Thunder Bay City Council is not likely to push back much against what is being asked for even if public opposition emerges given their performance last week largely endorsing the sale of public properties and development as proposed to build new density housing projects in established neighbourhoods. On the other hand, the debate will be interesting to monitor to see what finally emerges given that we are going into an municipal election year. 

 

 

Rising Crime in Canada: Evidence from Thunder Bay

 

Rising crime and perceptions of rising crime in Canadian urban areas have become more concerning as media reports increase and a recent study by the MacDonald-Laurier Institute provides some evidence to back up the feeling that crime is up.  The report looks at the last decade’s worth of police reported crime data for nine major Canadian urban centers: Calgary, Edmonton, Montreal, Ottawa, Peel, Toronto, Vancouver, Winnipeg, and York Region.  Essentially, crime and especially violent crime is up in all of these cities with sexual assaults in particular showing large increases.  Of course, this study omits a lot of cities and so of course the question that arises for inquiring local minds is how Thunder Bay has been doing over the last little while?  Is crime rising in Thunder Bay? Well, it depends on the time span you want to look at as well as the specific type of crime.  But overall, the feeling that crime is rising here is not misplaced.

 

Using police reported crime data from Statistics Canada, here is a quick snapshot of how some crime rates in Thunder Bay (crimes per 100,000 population) have been performing. Figure 1 plots the crime rate for total violent crimes and total property crimes for the period 1998 to 2023.  Over the long haul, the trends do not seem particularly concerning.  The property crime rate in 1998 was 6,285 crimes per 100,000 population and after 2009 it began declining quite steadily followed by a spike in 2019 and then further decline.  Between 1998 and 2023, the property crime rate fell from 6,285 crimes per 100,000 to 3,117 per 100,000 – a 50 percent drop.  

 

 

 

Violent crime between 1998 and 2023 has also dropped but not by as much.  It went from 2,401 violent crimes per 100,000 to 2,195 per 100,000 -a nearly 9 percent decline.  However, the violent crime rate seems to be broken into two phases.  It went from 2,401 in 1998 to a low of 1,414 in 2015 – a decline of 41 percent.  Since 2015, it has grown and by 2023 was, as noted, at 2,195 – an increase of 55 percent.  While violent crime is lower than 1998 that is small consolation given what appears to be a fairly rapid increase in recent years.

 

 

 

Figure 2 presents the percentage change in crime rates over a ten-year period – 2013 to 2023 – for a select number of crime categories.  The results paint a more complicated picture.  The total crime rates (all criminal code violations including traffic) are down 2.5 percent over the last ten years.  This seems to be driven in part by a decline in property crimes as the total property crime rate over the same period is down 13.4 percent.  However, over a ten-year period, the total violent crime rate is up nearly 39 percent.  Homicides are up 120 percent from 2013 (though these are two points in time.  Using a three-year moving average for 2012 and 2022, homicides are only up 87 percent if that makes you feel better).  Total sexual assaults are up 68 percent while total assaults in general are up 31 percent.   Impaired driving is up about 5 percent while robberies are up 39 percent. 

 

So, are perceptions of rising crime justified?  I would think so given that while overall crime rates might be down or flat, the rates for more serious crimes such as homicides, assaults and robbery are up.  There you have it.

Thunder Bay 2023 Budget Is Out: Highest Tax Levy Increase Since 2015 Proposed

 The City of Thunder Bay has released its proposed 2023 budget and it looks like the biggest tax increase in recent years.  The proposed budget is increasing the tax levy by  6.18 percent (just under 6 percent after tax base growth) which will raise the total tax levy by nearly 13 million dollars and bring the total tax levy to over 220 million dollars.  As the accompanying figure shows, this will be the largest tax increase since at least 2015 and probably since 2006.  In terms of tax levy increases for the 1991 to 2023 period,  since 1991, Thunder Bay tax levy increases have ranged from a high of almost 22 percent in 1998 to a low of -1.7 percent in 1995.  If enacted, this proposed levy increase will be the fifth highest since 1991.  The current Mayor campaigned on keeping the tax increase low and reduce bureaucracy but this proposed budget comes apparently with an additional 50 full time equivalent employees.  With inflation running at over 6 percent, the proposed budget comes pretty close to the inflation rate which is not unexpected as signals to this effect have been ongoing for months.   However, one suspects the Mayor will at least make an effort at vocal displeasure at this increase given that it is the fifth highest increase since 1991, the highest increase in nearly twenty years and he was the mayor from 1997 to 2003 which means he was also in office as the Mayor during the highest levy increase in the 1991 to 2023 period.  A legacy associated with some of the highest tax increases in Thunder Bay's municipal fiscal history is not something the mayor probably is interested in.  The reaction of the rest of council and the public will be key.  These are of course very preliminary numbers and reaction on my part and the full budget has yet to be posted on the city web site at the time of writing but will take a look at the details in coming days.

Thunder Bay's Tax Levy Debate

It would appear that the municipal election campaign is starting to heat up with the outgoing Mayor taking issue with the Thunder Bay Chamber of Commerce's recent election policy document which among things argues that the City of Thunder Bay's tax levies have increased by an annual average of 3.36 percent over the last decade.  Their graph is for the period 2012 to 2022 which includes projections for the 2018 to 2022 period which is not exactly the last decade. The Mayor maintains that the average tax levy change over the past eight years is only 2.4 percent - after new growth in the tax base was factored in.

This is all really quite entertaining because what matters is the increase in the total tax levy - that is what is being drawn from the tax base and used to fund spending.  The tax levy is essentially an expenditure estimate for taxpayer assisted spending and in the end what matters is the total amount of the revenue taken in and its growth and not whether some of it comes from the existing base and some of it is coming from new assessment growth.  The latter argument is really only being advanced to deflect attention from the overall increases.


So, what are the numbers?  Well, here is my two cents worth.  The accompanying figure plots the annual tax levy increase for the period 2008 to 2018 based on total tax revenue numbers from the Financial Information Returns from the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing (with the exception of the last couple of years which come from City of Thunder Bay budget documents).  If you take the average, it comes out to comes out to 3.3 percent which is pretty close to the Chamber estimate.  If you take the average for only the 2011 to 2018 period, you get an average of 3.4 percent.  The last four years average out to 3.7 percent which is a rate well in excess of the rates of inflation and income growth in this city but the number is skewed by the 5.7 increase in 2015 - the year right after the last election. In the end, the tax levy in Thunder Bay has increased at an average of over 3 percent annually for the last decade and based on the chamber numbers is projected to continue doing so.