It would appear that Thunder Bay City Council is still
maintaining its cone of silence regarding the plague of plumbing problems that
have afflicted numerous
homeowners, not to mention businesses and other institutions in the city. Residents are growing
increasingly frustrated by the silence in light of evidence that hundreds
if not thousands of households across the city have been hit by leaks in their
indoor copper plumbing and in many cases leaks in their city connection line to
the water main. The expense for some
homeowners is running in the tens of thousands of dollars including the hundreds
of dollars in fees that the City is charging to shut off and turn back on water
at the shutoff valves in order to effect repairs.
Thunder Bay has had a long
history of water system and supply issues and this is the latest installment
in what is going to be a very expensive saga.
Given that these issues have emerged in the wake of the addition of
sodium hydroxide to the water supply to combat lead pipes affecting about 8,700
residents in older neighborhoods, the reluctance of the City to comment is
understandable. Correlation is not necessarily
causation, but the timing of the leaks in the wake of the sodium hydroxide addition is more than suspicious. On the other hand, there
needs to be some public effort made to deal with the problems and the business
as usual approach of the City and the accompanying silence of the mayor and
councillors is not what our government should be doing. We do not elect our politicians to ignore us.
The Mayor and Council are our elected representatives and
their silence in what are now twin pandemics – COVID and the plumbing plague –
essentially is leaving many of us on our own to deal with these issues while they
pursue business as usual. Indeed, this
week the Mayor apparently lobbied the provincial government on community
needs that included: Bombardier, operating funding to offset 2021 COVID-19
costs and lost revenues, infrastructure funding, and funding for additional
hires for long-term care and to cover increased costs associated with COVID-19. Nowhere was there public acknowledgement during
this “important opportunity to advocate for our community” of the woes
of so many local homeowners and residents.
The public needs to know that their municipal government is looking out
for them and it becomes apparent that they do not have our back – unless it is
to use it to carry the load of increased taxes to fund their priorities.
It would help immensely to know if there is anything we can
do as homeowners to preemptively deal with the leaky pipe problem. Are some neighborhoods affected more than
others? Is it a function of the age of
your homes? What signs should we be on
the lookout for to catch the problem early? Are houses near corners more susceptible
as some observations suggest? Is proximity to pumping stations a factor in
terms of water pressure or the amount of sodium hydroxide that was released? Instead,
we are left with cobbling together evidence from rumor and social media of
which the most important contribution to date is a Facebook page under the title of the
Thunder
Bay Leaky Pipe Club that now has nearly 700 members.
In the absence of publicly available evidence from the City
in terms of incidence and distribution, we are left to our own devices. For example, based on the above Facebook Page
discussions it would appear that the leaks are occurring all over the city,
even in newer subdivisions such as Parkdale.
However, there are particular concentrations in Northwood, River
Terrace/Fairbanks, John Street and Valleywood areas. Indeed, a drive down James
Street in Northwood a few weeks ago suggested that there was either a lot of landscaping
being done or there has been a veritable plague of leaky pipes. In the River Terrace neighborhood off John
Street – a subdivision of about 200 homes – based on the dug-up lawns and the
neighborhood stories – there have been 40 homes affected.
That is a 20 percent rate.
There are about 50,000 private households in Thunder Bay which suggests
that this problem may eventually affect 10,000 property owners. True, extrapolating
from one subdivision of 200 to the entire city is not good science but given
the absence of any official information it is the only analysis we can do. In the absence of numbers from the City as to
how much of a problem this is, we are left to wonder who is going to be next
and how much it is going to cost. Not
only are most of us working from home during the COVID-19 pandemic, but now we also
have to worry that we will be flooded out and hit with a ten-thousand-dollar
bill. As if there were not enough mental
health issues in Thunder Bay.
So, here it is. In Thunder
Bay right now, based on the homicide rate, you have about a 7 in 100,000 chance of
being murdered – in percent terms that is just over one-half of one percent. if you get COVID-19, you have about a 1
percent chance of dying from it given the numbers to date – 109 cases and 1
death. However, if you own a home in
Thunder Bay, you have a 20 percent change of leaky pipes occurring and a
plumbing bill that can range anywhere from a few hundred to many thousands of
dollars. Why is this not a priority? How the Mayor and Council can still look at
themselves in the mirror in the morning is beyond me.
