There have been a number of high-profile homicides in Hamilton and surrounding parts over the last few months with an estimated 12 homicides to date in Hamilton alone. With nearly three months to go, 2020 is shaping up to see Hamilton’s largest homicide total since 2013 when there 15 homicides. This inevitably sparks comparisons to other urban centres and Thunder Bay inevitably comes to mind because of its recent issues with homicides, but also because in many respects, the two communities share similarities.
Hamilton and Thunder Bay are both “lakeheads” with Hamilton at the head of Lake Ontario while Thunder Bay is at the head of navigation on Lake Superior. They both have histories as gritty industrial towns, saw the shedding of middle-class industrial jobs and several decades of economic hardship, and have social and poverty issues with segments of their populations. Both have had issues with inequality, racism, and the lack of housing for marginalized and homeless people.
However, there are also major differences. Hamilton is a larger urban centre clocking in at over 500,000 people whereas Thunder Bay hovers at about 120,000. Hamilton’s population has been growing over the last two decades while Thunder Bay’s has not. Hamilton’s economy has also been undergoing a substantial period of economic rejuvenation that has been creating jobs and investment. Building permits have been up three years in a row and Amazon recently announced a new distribution centre on the Mountain creating 1500 new jobs. Hamilton’s downtown is booming with construction projects.
Prior to the pandemic, the Conference Board for 2020 projected strength in non‐residential construction, in professional services, and in the finance, insurance, and real estate industry and expected real GDP growth of 1.7 per cent in Hamilton in 2020. The projection for Thunder Bay by comparison was for growth by 0.7 per cent in 2020, with only modest growth in the manufacturing and construction sectors.
But coming back to the main event, is Hamilton going to supplant Thunder Bay as the murder capital of Canada? Figure 1 plots the total annual number of homicides in Hamilton and Thunder Bay over the period 1981 to 2020 as obtained from Statistics Canada (1981 to 2018) and from media reports to date for 2019 and 2020. Being a much larger city in terms of population, Hamilton can be expected to have more homicides, but the gap has narrowed over time. In 2012 and 2014, Thunder Bay actually managed more homicides than Hamilton. Moreover, when a linear trend is fitted to the data, Hamilton has shown a distinct downward trend over time while Thunder Bay has shown the opposite.
The difference in the scale of the problems facing the two cities is even more apparent when homicides per 100,000 of population are examined in Figure 2. From 1981 to about 2007, the two cities track each other with a downward trend though Thunder Bay often exceeds Hamilton once homicides are adjusted for population size. However, there is a strong divergence after 2007 with Thunder Bay’s homicide rate soaring while Hamilton’s essentially flatten out based on the trend line (which is a polynomial fit this time to take into account the U-shaped nature of Thunder Bay’s data). Indeed, the estimated homicide rates for 2020 to date per 100,000 population are 2.1 for Hamilton and 6.8 for Thunder Bay.
It would appear that Hamilton is nowhere near wresting away Thunder Bay’s crown as the murder capital of Thunder Bay this year. Of course, one wonders if policing resource difference is factor, but that will be another post. Stay tuned and stay safe.